Skip to main content

Is Amnesty International Report on Assad Government Hangings, Propaganda?

There has been lots of suspicion lately about FakeNews, with much of the commentary from establishment types, saying it's from the Alternate News Media.
I'm not so sure that's right, as lately, well, as of the 2nd Iraq War, it has been increasingly the western Main Street Media, our Corporate Media titans that have been leading that charge. In my opinion of course - and that of many others.
In terms of this post, I'm posting a rebuttal to the report from two individuals, both Syrians. The translated, formated document is linked to my Google Drive. All I have done is format it in a way that's easier to read, rather than one sold block of single spaced text. Since this is a translation from Arabic to English and not done by a professional translation service, there are some mistakes in language. Not enough to obscure any meaning, in my opinion. I didn't want to correct those, as I wanted to keep it as close to virgin as possible.

It's a worthwhile read (below)!


Amnesty International report on Syria: a response from a Syrian dissident (former political prisoner living in Europe)

Of course, the Syrian regime committed and is committing and will continue to commit human rights violations but this is about the Amnesty International report on Syria.
Western human rights organizations--specifically Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch--don't have any credibility among most Arabs about human rights. Their reputation has sunk far lower ever since the Arab uprisings in 2011, where they have been rightly perceived as propaganda arms of Western governments.  So, I saw the report yesterday and read the Methodology section and immediately felt that it is not credible: given the mention of unnamed sources (not one of them willing to be identified and the reference to countries which host Syrian opposition groups).  But I am not an expert on those details and specifics.  I don't trust the Syrian regime, (and its sponsors) and I don't trust the Syrian rebels and their sponsors in the West and East.  
How to judge the report? I asked a well-known Syrian dissident who, due to his leftist underground activities, served years in Syrian jails and was subjected to torture by the regime.  His name is Nizar Nayouf.  He wrote me those responses, and I can't judge the validity of the specific answers, but given that there is no scrutiny by Western media to anything coming out, which is in sync with Western government propaganda on Syria, I thought it would be useful.  These are my (rush) translations (edited) of his answers:


" The white prison is the one in the shape of Mercedes.  It is the main building (the old and big).  As for the red prison, it is the new and small [structure], and contrary to what is contained in the report--which it seems does not distinguish between the two.  


The first was inaugurated in 1988 while the second was not inaugurated until 2001.  As for the main White building, it is quite impossible for it to accommodate 10,000 prisoners.  We know it inch by inch, and know how much it can accommodate, at maximum, and assuming you put 30 prisoners in a cell like pickles (or Syrian style pickles, makdus), it can't accommodate more than 4500 prisoners (in fact it was designed for 3000 prisoners).
The red building is much smaller and is exclusive to public defendants among the military members (traffic, desertion, various criminal offenses, etc), and can't accommodate more than 1800 prisoners, even if you put 3 on top of one another.  
Yes, paying money to achieve release is true.  I personally documented tens of cases, in which `Ali Haydar (minister of national reconciliation) was the mediator.  The talk of rape is lie on top of lie.  It has no basis in truth.  I challenge them...to show one case, not only now but also from the beginning of the era of Hafidh Al-Asad, whether with women or with men.
Yes, there were rape cases with tools (like raping around ten young women from Communist Action Party, and others, with soft drink bottles.  
There is nothing in official papers which prisoners sign something called Sidnaya prison. This is the popular name and not the official name*.   And this reveals the lies about them signing papers indicating that they were "from Sidnaya prison".  
Prisoners are not moved from prisons to On-site Courts in Al-Qabun.  The on-site courts move to prisons and hold its trials there, especially now as the Al-Qabun area is targeted by the fire of the rebels and is not safe at all.  
As for the length of the trials, it is one minute or two, and that is true since the 1980s till now.  They admit that on-site trials' rulings require the signature of the president or the Minister of Defense and yet they say in another section that execution is approved only by the members of the court and officers with it.  They claim that the second on-site court was formed to accommodate after the crisis, and this is a lie and show ignorance or fabrication.

The on-site court (first and second) have been in existence since 1968, and the Palestinian colonel, Salah ad-Din Al-Ma`ani, was chief of the second on-site courts since the 1980s.  He was the one who was in charge of trial of Muslim Brotherhood, along with Sulayman Al-Khatib.  
As for the requirement of confessions by prisoners while they are blindfolded, this was ended by an order from Hafidh Al-Asad in 1998 or 1999, as far as I can remember, but I don't know if this practice was resumed.  
There is no representative of the mukhabarat in the Hay'at Al--Mahkamah Al-Maydaniyyah, and thus he does not sign on any ruling, contrary to what is claimed by the report.  There is a mess in what they say that the head of the on-site court is the military prosecutor, (p. 20) and this is real rubbish.  
The military prosecutor’s job is quite different from the chief of the on-site court, and is the chief military prosecutor in the military district administration.  They say that those who are on death row are gathered in the red building (section B).  
But they said that the red boiling (p. 12) which is on the shame pf Mercedes, which is in fact the old building, and is thus baseless as I indicated above.  And in the old building there are no cells except solitary confinement cells (one meter by two meters) under ground.  And they are for punishment and is limited in numbers.

As for the section B, it is like other sections (10 beds on the right and 10 on the left, three stories over ground).  
The thing that most got my attention was "the transfer of the prisoners from the red building and white building in trucks and cars".  When one hears this, one thinks that the distance between the two buildings is in kilometers when they are less than 120 meters apart.  
The report says (p. 2) that the "commander of the southern front group (firqah) attends the executions.  There is nothing in the Syrian Army which is called "commander of the Southern Group 13 or northern or Western or any other direction.
 
On page 32, it says that the picture is of the cemetery of  martyrs south of Damascus.  The report says that it was expanded substantially between 2014 and 2016 and that long tunnels were dug in them, implying that they were used to bury those who were executed.  
This is silly beyond silly.  In the martyrs cemetery no one can be buried there except the martyrs of the army, even if there is an intercession by Muhammad or Jesus or Hafidh Al-Asad himself.  And contrary to what they say, and the picture damns them, because it shows the increase in the number of victims of the army.
 
On p. 35, and elsewhere, they talk about forcing "prisoners to rape one another".  This is despicable fabrication which is baseless, and is psychologically impossible under those conditions.  (Is it possible for any person in the world to get an erection to rape another person who is tied and is under torture?)  
If the lying witness were to say that he was raped with sticks, i would have believed it because this happened sometimes with public defense prisoners as I indicated above.  

On page 43, there is a copy of certificate of death which reveals that it belongs to the Minister of Interior, but the certificate says that death was in "Military Tirshrin Hospital", which belongs to the Ministry of Defense.  
This didn't happen, and can't happen.  In cases of death in a military hospital or in detention centers belonging to Military Intelligence, the certificates show "Army or Armed Forces, Directorate of Military Medical Services", or hospital x.  

One of the most amusing--if there is amusement in tragedies--contents of the report is what appears on page 44, where it talks about "tens of thousands" (i.e. over 30,000 or at least 18,000) who died under torture or for other reasons in Sidnaya prison in five years but it says: "but we only were able to obtain the names of 375 people only".  

What the report says about the kinds of mistreatment and torture and criminality is generally true.  The world has not seen more savage prisons than the 18 prisons of the Iraqi (Saddamist) and Syrian prisons since the times of Nazism and Fascism in WWII.  And anything which is reported in this context can be simply believed.  We have seen it with our own eyes and lived it personally, although there were orders too--to be fair--that the torture of leftists and nationalists be less severe than the savage torture of Islamists."


* I pointed to Nizar this morning that the official Syrian regime statement issued today used the name of Sidnaya prison, and he said that it was the first time as they did not want to use the official name of First Military Prison.  


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Christopher Hitchens: Answers Why He Preached Against the Theocracy Belief System

Brilliant! Mr. Hitchens just gave voice to what I sincerely believe, but couldn't verbalize.

I was raised in one of those Plymouth Brethren Christian homes, where belief in the End of Times, especially the book of Revelations in the Bible was preached daily. One can't be saved by good deeds, but by being a Born Again Christian for the coming Rapture and End of Times.


As far as I'm concerned, that belief system is no different than the WahabiMuslim belief system. They both can go to hell! Evil is right!


Related articlesJehovah's Witness agrees not to show son religious cartoons because of risk of 'emotional damage'Federal court allows Mississippi to let businesses and government employees cite religious beliefs to refuse service to LGBT peopleWithout the Christian Right, There'd Be No President Trump: What Do They Want in Exchange?That Time I Tried to Lose My Virginity to a Christian Who Liked to Get Off to the Bible4 Reasons the Christian Right's Claims…

Iraqi Security Update Ending March 30 2017

English: Market in Mosul. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)Reprinted brief synopsis via ISHM

Key Takeaways:

Hundreds of Civilian Casualties in Western Mosul Blamed on Coalition Airstrikes - On March 17, U.S.-led international coalition warplanes carried out airstrikes on a suspected ISIS location in the al-Jadida neighborhood of western Mosul. The airstrikes leveled multiple buildings, and likely caused the deaths of an estimated 101 to 263 civilians. Both Iraq’s Defense Minister Irfan Hiyali and U.S. Central Command have ordered inquiries into the incident. On March 28, Lt. General Stephen Townsend, commander of Operation Inherent Resolve, told reporters that “if we did it - and there is a fair chance that we did - it was an unintentional accident of war, and we will transparently report it to you when we’re ready.” A sharp rise in civilian casualties in Mosul has outraged several Iraqi politicians and members of the public - most of whom do not accept an alternative narrative circulating in…

Brave Yazidi Fighter Soldiers On Looking for his Lost Family in Iraq

A Yazidi fighter who for almost 3 years has been without his family recounts the terror of ISIS on August the 3rd 2014 on his village and his current mission to fight ISIS until his last breath to liberate his wife and see his child. We are all PMU in this war and we are all fighting to rescue our families. We are all hoping we find his wife and his children safe and alive. No kidding! I hope it ends well for this man - Cannot imagine the pain he must be going through. Please watch the video below.


Related articlesFreed ISIS child soldier recounts horrors of brutal training, years of tortureYazidi activist weary after years of anti-ISIS campaigningNearly 10,000 Yazidis killed, kidnapped by Islamic State in 2014, study findsWorld Silent about ISIS Massacre of Afghans'ISIL... can't take away our faith': Yazidis defy Islamic State with prayer and pilgrimageSurvivor Of ISIS Terror Reveals The Horror Of Living Under Islamic Tyranny: "My Mother Saw Them Killing My Brothers …